Karsten Riise's Blog

Scotland's Independence - the Irish Border ... and the US

June 17, 2019
Print

It is great foot-work of Scotland to communicate the message of Independence to the EU

Resistance to Scottish Independence will come – and perhaps even also from a corner not in England, but across the pond.

The UK is a key US ally.

Scotland has a strategic location for UK sea-air control of the northern entrance to the North-Sea, of Scandinavia and the North Atlantic.


2014_09_17t201126z_1021709870_gm1ea9i0bha01_rtrmadp_3_scotland_independence.jpg

Source: s.yimg.com


Scotland’s Independence will mean severely breaking up the unity and power of the UK. Hence, Independence for Scotland will unavoidably lead to a significant weakening of the US alliance-network and vital US-linkages across the Atlantic. Should Northern Ireland also leave the UK, the UK as a once big ally of the USA, will be reduced to England and Wales. Most of the UK population would still reside in England, but big and vital parts of the territory and international clout of the UK would be gone. What Wales in that case might decide, we shall not discuss here.

Northern Ireland does not have the same degree of strategic position for sea-air control as Scotland. However, should Scotland leave the UK, the strategic importance of Northern Ireland will increase many times for UK-US force-projection and logistics in the Atlantic. In contrast to the UK, the Republic of Ireland (though member of the EU) is not a NATO country.

Hence, if both Scotland gains Independence (and probably re-joins the EU) and Northern Ireland within the next decade or two reunites with the Republic of Ireland (and thereby automatically reunites with the EU), all that can develop into a 4-double whammy for the USA: Both in terms of (A) twice breaking up the political power of the UK as a key US ally, and also (B) for twice a degradation of UK-US areas for sea/air-operations.

After Brexit (if it materializes), such developments can become a gain for the EU – but a severe loss for the US.
The US is obviously not shy to actively meddle in internal European politics, trying to block a particular European politician (Jeremy Corbyn) from becoming Prime Minister.

On that background, the US must certainly also be regarded as willing and able to meddle in seen and unseen ways against Scotland’s Independence – because on this issue the long-term strategic stakes are much-much higher for the US than on the temporary and more minor issue of who is Prime Minister of the UK for a few years. Along the same lines of argument, the US might also not be willing to just passively look by, if the people of Northern Ireland with demographic change strengthening the Catholics should gain mood and momentum to reunite with the rest of Ireland.

On these issues, the EU might end up finding itself having not exactly the same interests (and methods) as the US.

Share this article

Poll conducted

  1. Korean Peninsula Crisis Has no Military Solution. How Can It Be Solved?
    Demilitarization of the region based on Russia-China "Dual Freeze" proposal  
     36 (35%)
    Restoring multilateral negotiation process without any preliminary conditions  
     27 (26%)
    While the situation benefits Kim Jong-un's and Trump's domestic agenda, there will be no solution  
     22 (21%)
    Armed conflict still cannot be avoided  
     12 (12%)
    Stonger deterrence on behalf of the U.S. through modernization of military infrastructure in the region  
     4 (4%)
    Toughening economic sanctions against North Korea  
     2 (2%)
 
For business
For researchers
For students